Dear Author:
March 1st, 2012
You have seven (yes seven!) main characters. Five are boys, two are girls. You have introduced all five boys with action, either in the present or a quick flashback. Well done.
Of the two girls, one is described as having an “athletic body with curves in all the right places” who “should not be allowed to walk around school with normal guys”. The other girl is only described as being the first one’s friend. This is not just sexist, it’s bad writing.
You created a completely flat character (except in the chest department) and another who is so thin on the page she almost doesn’t exist. And don’t give me the that’s-what-the-protagonist-perceives crap. Any protagonist who isn’t a complete asshole or profoundly mentally disturbed will notice a woman’s actions just as well as they notice a man’s. I’m not saying boys don’t notice girls’ bodies, but those two girls are not constantly posing in hopes your main dude will look at them.
This is a book for teens, damn it. You have a responsibility to write female characters as actual characters. Our society dehumanizes women enough. It doesn’t need your help. You don’t have to make them Buffy the Vampire Slayer or Alice from Resident Evil (rah!), but you do have to make them human. Also, you are a writer. Fleshing out characters is your mother-fucking job.
In conclusion, I will finish reading your book. I want to write a critical essay on how otherwise competent writers don’t bother to write their female characters. You aren’t mentioned by name here, but you will be there. Frankly, the only reason I’m not mentioning your name here is because I haven’t finished the book yet. I’m holding out some hope that part of your protagonist’s character arc is to realize that the girls are people.
Sincerely,
Me

